A First-Timer’s Guide to Therapy: What to Expect and How to Make the Most of It

THRIVE IN ‘25!

A First-Timer’s Guide to Therapy: What to Expect and How to Make the Most of It

Deciding to start therapy for the first time can be a mix of excitement, curiosity, and even nervousness. It’s normal to wonder, What will the sessions be like? Will it really help me? As a therapist, I’ve worked with many first-time clients who felt exactly the same. Let’s explore what therapy is really like and share some tips to help you get started.

“I Was So Nervous at First”

Jessica, a 28-year-old teacher, came to her first session feeling anxious. “I don’t even know where to start,” she said, twisting her hands in her lap.

For many first-time clients, this is the biggest worry: what to say. But here’s the good news—you don’t need to have everything figured out before starting therapy. In fact, your therapist’s job is to guide the conversation and help you uncover what’s important.

In Jessica’s case, we began by talking about what brought her to therapy: stress at work and difficulty sleeping. From there, the conversation naturally flowed, and by the end of the session, she felt relieved and hopeful.

Takeaway: You don’t need to have a “perfect reason” for starting therapy. Just showing up is enough.

Finding the Right Therapist

David, a 40-year-old accountant, shared this after his first session: “I didn’t feel a connection with the first therapist I met. But when I found someone who really understood my struggles, it made all the difference.”

Therapy is most effective when you feel comfortable and understood by your therapist. If your first experience doesn’t feel like a good fit, don’t be discouraged. It’s okay to “shop around” until you find someone who aligns with your needs and personality.

David eventually found a therapist who specialized in managing anxiety, and their approach to Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) helped him feel more in control of his thoughts and emotions.

Takeaway: It’s okay to try different therapists. Finding the right match is key to your success.

“What Will We Even Talk About?”

Marisa, a 34-year-old mom, came to therapy because she felt overwhelmed balancing work and family life. “I wasn’t sure what I’d say,” she admitted, “but once I started talking, it all just came out.”

Many people worry about “not having enough to say” in therapy. But once the conversation begins, most clients find that they have more to share than they realized. In Marisa’s case, we started with her biggest source of stress: feeling like she wasn’t “doing enough” for her family. This opened the door to discussing self-care and setting boundaries, which became key themes in our work together.

Takeaway: Therapy is a safe space where you can share as much—or as little—as you feel comfortable. Your therapist will guide the session and help you explore what matters most.

Managing Expectations

“I thought therapy would fix everything after a couple of sessions,” said Amir, a 25-year-old grad student. “But it’s more like building a muscle—it takes time and effort.”

Amir’s experience is common. Therapy isn’t a quick fix; it’s a process of growth and discovery. Some sessions may feel deeply impactful, while others might feel slower. This is normal and part of the journey.

Over time, Amir began noticing subtle but meaningful changes—he felt less overwhelmed by school, started setting healthier boundaries, and gained a better understanding of himself.

Takeaway: Therapy takes time, but the gradual progress is worth it. Celebrate small wins along the way.

Tips for First-Time Therapy Seekers

1. Ask Questions: During your first session, ask anything on your mind: “What’s your approach to therapy?” or “How do you typically work with clients like me?”

2. Be Honest: You don’t need to hide your feelings or thoughts. Your therapist is here to help, not judge.

3. Be Open to Homework: Some therapists might suggest journaling, mindfulness exercises, or small changes to try between sessions. These tools can help deepen your progress.

4. Prioritize Consistency: Regular sessions help build trust and momentum in your work together.

Your First Step Toward Healing

Therapy is a gift you give yourself—a space to explore, heal, and grow. Whether you’re navigating stress, grief, relationship challenges, or just feeling stuck, therapy can help you find clarity and strength. Remember, taking that first step is the hardest part. Once you’re there, you’ll discover a process that’s designed to meet you exactly where you are.

If you’re considering therapy and want to learn more, I’m here to help. Contact me to schedule a consultation and start your journey toward a healthier, more fulfilling life.